How I Manage Caffeine Sensitivity as a Regular Coffee Drinker

Photo by Andrew Neel

I’ve written previously about the increasingly negative effects of alcohol as I aged. My body was developing a lower tolerance for alcohol, where just a couple of beers negatively affected not only my quality of sleep but also my overall energy level the next day. That led me to quit drinking over five years ago.

Another thing I’ve noticed as I get older is my heightened sensitivity to caffeine. I’ve been a regular coffee drinker my entire adult life. While the caffeine sensitivity is much less pronounced than that of alcohol, I’ve decided to proactively alter my caffeine consumption habits.

I have always loved having coffee in the morning and would even indulge in an afternoon cup now and then. While I had no problem giving up alcohol, I decided I’m not giving up coffee.

Research shows that older adults clear caffeine from the body more slowly than younger adults. In one study, coffee drinkers aged 65–70 took 33% longer to metabolize caffeine than younger participants. This can lead to unpleasant symptoms, including anxiety, irritability, and difficulty sleeping.

Caffeine is metabolized in the liver. As we age, the enzymes that process caffeine can become less efficient, so caffeine stays in the body longer. This means the same amount of coffee will have a more amplified effect.

An 8-ounce cup of regular coffee contains 80 to 100 milligrams of caffeine. The FDA’s recommended limit is 400 milligrams per person per day, equivalent to about four cups of coffee.

I typically drink three to four cups (24 to 32 ounces) of black coffee (no cream, no sugar) a day, which is about 300 to 400 milligrams of caffeine. I’ve decided to limit my daily caffeine intake to 100 to 200 milligrams.

Reducing my intake to 200 milligrams per day was easy. I continued to drink three to four cups, but I switched to a half-caf/half-decaf blend. I also switched to dark roast coffees, which contain a bit less caffeine than light or medium roasts.

Nowadays, I usually consume closer to 100 milligrams of caffeine per day. I often make a 25% caffeine/75% decaf blend. Four cups still keep me at or below the 100-milligram target.

Because caffeine can disrupt sleep even when consumed 6 to 8 hours before bedtime, I drink decaf on the rare occasions I have it in the afternoon. Plus, decaf retains most of the beneficial polyphenols found in regular coffee.

I’m also experimenting with a French-roast chicory coffee alternative for a coffee-like experience without the caffeine. I either mix it with my regular coffee or drink it on its own. It’s just another option besides decaf.

Caffeine interacts with many medications, sometimes reducing their effectiveness by half. I’m healthy and don’t take any medications. This isn’t an issue for me, but others may need to take this into account if they are taking medications.

While coffee and tea are the primary sources of caffeine for most people, other foods and beverages contain varying amounts of this stimulant. For example, chocolate, energy drinks, sodas, and some medications may contain caffeine.

My source of caffeine is coffee. I don’t drink sodas, and I stay away from those horribly unhealthy energy drinks. I rarely drink tea or eat chocolate, and I don’t take any medications.

Coffee and alcohol were part of my social rituals. But nowadays, I stick to sparkling water or a non-alcoholic beer at social gatherings. For morning social meetups with friends, I have my caf/decaf mix or simply decaf coffee.

Although I quit drinking alcohol in 2021, I continue to make coffee a regular part of my life. I’m able to enjoy it while managing my mild caffeine sensitivity.

It has been essential for me to be mindful of what I put into my body and how it may affect my sleep, anxiety, and overall well-being. I pay attention to how my body responds and act accordingly. I’ve eliminated certain things that have negatively impacted me over the years.

Fortunately, I can continue to indulge in coffee without any adverse effects. It still provides a sense of enjoyment and relaxation. It is one of my simple pleasures in life, and I’m happy to continue to include it in my daily routine.

=====

I live and travel out of my SUV. You can follow my adventures on Facebook and Instagram